Over the last six years we have tried most of the major flatbed scanners and several drum scanners. Here are the results so far.

Home| A to Z INDEX| Site Map| FREE REPORTS| Training| Services| FLAAR at BGSU| FLAAR at UFM| Help

 

Can a drum scanner really scan better than a high-end flatbed scanner?

Our initial experience with the ICG drum scanner is favorable. It is easy to use, indeed probably even I can learn to use it. So much for the myth that you have to be trained for years to use a drum scanner. That was a decade ago. Today the equipment and the software is easier to operate.

ICG drum scanner

One professional prepress shop had an Optronics. The owner reported it was so awful that they got better scans from a Umax. This experienced prepress scanner operator subsequently bought a Creo EverSmart Pro II flatbed scanner after reading the reviews by Nicholas Hellmuth. In fairness to Optronics, I presume (I hope) that most of their scanners produce better scans than a $2000 Umax PowerLook III, but at least one lemon came off their assembly line and that is not good for convincing people to buy that brand when there are other perfectly good brands to buy.

ICG drum scanner
ICG drum scanner

In the meantime Optronics as a scanner has evidently ceased to exist.

Another prepress scanner operator reported "I have operated a Howtek 2500 and Cezanne (FT-s5000) in another prepress company for two years. Cezanne is really a good high-end flatbed scanner that is 4 times faster than Howtek and much easier to use. But it is a bit incapable of capturing highlights, and produces grainy results. These two drawbacks are crucial.

This reveals that many factors are at play, both hardware, optics, and software. Of course the grainy results are due to film grain. This is not the fault of the scanner, but is part of the physics and chemistry of film, especially 35mm transparencies.

The BEST bag in the photograph is the same color as the ICG drum scanner but is not part of the system; I just happen to prefer BEST color management RIP for large format printers and happened to have a BEST bag while I was visiting Global Graphics hardware at the recent DRUPA trade show.

Since May Global Graphics no longer makes ICG drum scanners. If the ICG drum scanner surfaces under a new name and new management, we will report it.

At Photokina tradeshow in September we will also be curious to see what other drum scanner companies no longer exist. At Photokina 2000 there was a new Swiss drum scanner and several other European makes and models. Most went the way of the dinosaur. We hope ICG survives, since it was far superior to cheaper drum scanners which we tried out.

You can ask for the FLAAR report on scanners for prepress, or FLAAR report on scanners for fine art giclée.

FLAAR Premium Report - Series on Scanners

FLAAR now has a great variety of reports, where you can find practical information,
help and tips about which you need.

 

 

Drum scanners
Directory
User report
Howtek
Aztec scanner software
ICG
Contex

 
Specials Sets FLAAR
Premium Reports
.. Giclee-Decor Set
.. Set for Print for Pay
.. Set for CAD and GIS
.. Indoor-Outdoor Print Set
.. Enterprise Set: corporations, government, museums
FLAAR
Premium Reports

NEW! Scanners
.. Media and Inks
.. Color Management
.. RIPs for Inkjet Printers

.. Fine Art Giclee Printers
.. Solvent Ink Printers
.. UV Curable Ink Flatbeds

.. Wide Format Printers for Signs
.. Wide Format Printers for Photo-Realistic Quality
.. Surviving in the Wide Format Printing World

.. Bonus Reports

 
FLAAR
Free Reports

.. Previews Self Download
..
Free FLAAR Reports


.. About FLAAR
..
List FLAAR Reports

..
Digital Photo Textbooks
 
.. Cameras
   
.. Drum scanners
.. Slide scanner
.. Reprographic system
.. Wide format scanners
.. Sheet-fed scanners
.. Scan to print system
.. Accessories
.. Copy stand
 
.. Printers
.. Media
.. Software
.. Storage
.. Equipment
.. Book Reviews
.. Tradeshows
Volunteering
Meet Dr. Hellmuth
Privacy Statement
Links added Mar. 2002, updated July 31, 2002,
Most recent updated November 04, 2004, redesigned January 2004
FLAAR Information Network.
© 2001- 2007 All rights reserved

Privacy Statement | About the website | Site Map | Back to top

Any problem with this site please report it to webmaster@flaar.org , or if you note any error, omission, or have a different opinion on a review,
please contact the review editor, ReaderService@FLAAR.org, or find out how to meet Nicholas Hellmuth and speak with him personally